by Dr. Hatem BAZIAN*
Palestine, a gnawing wound eating away at the exposed soul and flesh of Palestinians living under occupation, is facing, yet, another orchestrated episode of Israeli military and settler’s violence. Where to begin the story in this well-designed Greek tragedy! We have multiple beginnings, detours, reverses, but for sure, no end in sight. Even if, a possible end draws near, destruction is unleashed faster than lightning. Now, the news outlets are interested in what is going on since “violence has returned” implying that it was on vacation or possibly attending the United Nations General Assembly meetings in New York. Violence just came back from vacation in time to cause death and mayhem. Violence never left Palestine and in fact, has been sitting center stage daily eating away at the insides of people; but no one notices and no one cares.
You see violence is a very difficult word to comprehend when it comes to Palestine. The reality is that “violence” has been imprinted onto Palestinian minds and regulates their daily lives. Violence is the norm since the Israeli occupation injures and peals away parts of Palestinians’ souls on a daily basis in a methodically sadistic way. Israel’s structured violence reaches Palestinians’ innermost being and attempts to deny the existence of a free, independent and dignified human who are named — Palestinians. The Israeli violence is the type that denies the existence of a people and creates an absence despite the physical presence.
The Palestinians face the violence of erasure that manages to wipe out the violence that is committed against them. They are an occupied and dispossessed population. More insidiously, Israel’s violence is normalized and regularized while granted “legal” lease by the international community to pummel the occupied population under the rubric of “self-defense” against its captive/imprisoned victims. One would not permit or praise prison guards when they pummel shackled prisoners, but indeed, this is what is done when Israel unleashes violence upon the Palestinians with weapons and funds provided by the international community! Palestinians are seeking protection from an international community that has become accustomed to selling bombs and weapons to Israel, as well as, provide protection in legal bodies that might investigate repeated war crimes against an occupied population.
An occupying power, asserting the right to self-defense against an occupied population that it exercises total control over and regulates every miniscule detail of his/hers daily life, should be seen as a mockery to the logic of self-defense. Choking a person to death, then claiming self-defense when the person in vain attempts kicking and screaming, is not a valid excuse nor should stand under the scrutiny of international law. But alas, the guardians of the law have implicated themselves in the crime. Indeed, the real problem is that international law and the agents acting upon it provide the tools and weapons for the murderer to choke the victim in a professional and well-tested manner.
The US, EU, Russia, China, India, Arab and Muslim states, as well as other international actors, are pre-occupied in working out their own strategic interests and Israel is intertwined with all of them in all types of machinations, weapons sales, covert operations and dirty games. Palestinians face Israel’s violence and erasure, Arab and Muslim world machinations (for their own distorted lease on seats of power) and US and EU imperial designs in the region for oil and strategic positioning against Russia and China. Palestine faces repeated and multiple acts of violence, but are only brought into the global discussion to be asked about violence and how they need to provide protection to their tormentors: the Israeli occupying power and all their settlers.
The news flashes back and forth posing the question whether the new “cycle of violence” is the start of the 3rd intifada, but not bothering to stop and think of the names, faces, stories, dreams and aspiration of a people who have been crushed way too many times to count, and double-crossed by friend and foe alike enough times to die while living. Third intifada or 14th, is not the issue, but focusing on the event as if the media and talking heads are looking forward to another Super Bowl or World Cup, wall to wall coverage with the outcome already known and not in any doubt. Covering Palestine while erasing it is a skill and a talent that is honed by reporters and media outlets attuned to the global market and job security, whereby, Palestinians are the props for narrating Israel and its stories rather than its victims. The story is about Palestine, but Palestinians are spoken for, and never allowed to speak on their own accord.
Here we have an occupied Palestinian population facing the fourth or possibly fifth most powerful army in the world equipped with every possible death machine the world has made including 500–600 nuclear warheads, and yet, we expect a different outcome. Pummeling Palestinians has become a sadistic pastime endeavor for an Israeli government and society that has turned fascistically callous toward the daily pain and suffering inflicted on its captive prey. What else can one call the utter disdain and total disregard for the value of a Palestinian life other than sadistic fascism that is clothed in religious purpose?
In reality, the Palestinians are the little David who were part of a colonized third world, indigenous, pre-industrial, pre-capitalist, agrarian and shared cropping agricultural based society with a highly distorted, colonially appointed and dysfunctional leadership facing the Zionist Goliath supported initially by a British colonial Goliath, then adopted by an American imperial Goliath, to be funded and nurtured into hegemonic power by the combined wealth and strength of multiple Goliaths, including those in the Arab and Muslim world who worked to strike their own deals to secure seats of power at the expense of the Palestinians. If honesty on the global stage could be entertained for a brief moment, then the real surprise and shock for many is that the little Palestinian David is still hanging around, standing and making noise after facing such overwhelming odds.
The death of 18-month-old Ali Dawabsheh, his father Saad, mother Reham and severely injured 4-year-old brother should ring the alarm bells inside and outside Palestine. However, the Israeli government arresting Meir Ettinger and handing down a six-month sentence only for leading an extremist group and not the murder of the family, is a clear example of the fascist problem at hand. Violence, death and burning flesh and crop are normal daily routines for Palestinians living under occupation. But their voices, names and stories are not allowed to be permanent and to register and to represent real humans deserving of justice, freedom and dignity.
I don’t see a cycle of violence, rather a pure and capable structured violence that is meted against the population daily and intended to humiliate, belittle, degrade and cause a slow and methodical death. The Apartheid Wall is a structured violence that is dissecting Palestinian towns, villages and cities like a razorblade cutting the metaphorical collective Palestinian body. Just like the little bully standing tall over an anthill, the Apartheid Wall is the symbol of the permanent Israeli bully engaged in taunting, stealing and devouring Palestine at every corner.
Violence of the settlements and settlers who are daily goading the Palestinians by burning crops, stealing water, taking land and building incoherent structures that protrude like a sore thumb on the environment and the surroundings. Architecture of occupation emerges from the confines of colonial discourses rooted in racism, power, control and domination, while exuding an all-around ugliness of taste and a corruption of the human spirit. A type of violence that is committed against the land itself, topography, mountains and valleys that are transfigured in the occupation process and correspond to the epistemic that shaped the crime in the first place. The ultimate sign of Israel’s ethical and moral bankruptcy is visible in the violence committed against olive trees and grape orchards but yet environmentalists in the West are silent about it.
Violence is ever-present in Israel’s actions toward the Palestinians. The violence in the color coding of car license plates, I.D. cards and systems of control that are designed to count the number while discounting the person indicated by the given document. This is the violence of being counted as a biological substance and discounted as a human, at the same moment, by a young soldier acting out his sense of control and power over men and women the age of his parents and grandparents. Yet, what is more violent, is the insistence of this young soldier to intentionally call the old man with a feminine pronoun and the women with a masculine one, while all the while, wearing a smirk as if he/she had conquered the seven heavens. How do you measure this violence and why could we record or indicate the daily un-cycle, pro-active, one-sided cycle of violence perpetrated on the Palestinians!
The violence of the checkpoints is the cancer of the occupation setting on top of the metaphorical Palestinian chest and preventing it from breathing and leading to slow suffocating death. Freedom of movement is a basic human right- this is indubitably denied to Palestinians. This includes in their own private lands you find settlers and soldiers alike interfering to make sure that Israel’s otherization and racism toward them is felt by every individual young or old. Viewing long lines upon long lines waiting for hours to go through metal gates and corralling pens that had it been made for cattle they would have complained that they are unfit for them and damages the capacity of the animal to be healthy and normal. Hours upon hours, young and old, sick or healthy, running late or arriving early the checkpoints are intended to stick the sharp nails of the occupation into the depth of people’s minds and souls. You are not human, not even a cattle but a biological material that is reduced to nothingness at the hands of soldiers well acquainted to the task of dehumanization, and worst yet, they consider it a religious or national duty.
In the face of all this, one would expect Palestinians to lose their humanity and become that which the occupation has ascribed to them — a nameless and faceless people emptied of meaning; but this is not the case. The Palestinians continue to write chapter after chapter in creativity, in living and resisting, as well as, the ability to be global while confined to the local prisons of Israel and its client the PA. Even in the middle of this 70 year old colonial dispossession and layered violence, the Palestinians always manage to think of the struggles of others and express meaningful solidarity whether in South Africa, El Salvador, Vietnam, and Ireland in the past and Syria, Iraq, Libya, Kashmir and Yemen to name the few in the present.
More critically, Palestinians have always expressed a close affinity to the cause of African Americans and Native Americans, a concern and a solidarity that has a long and complex history to it, including Malcolm X’s memorable visit to the Gaza Strip in 1964. It is the mark of strength and greatness to think and act in solidarity with others while facing the darkest moments and the multiple brutalities and erasures in one’s own history. Palestine has been the site of building and reaffirming global solidarity that is rooted in calls for freedom, dignity and economic wellbeing for all and not only for the few.
The prisons, checkpoints, settlements, bypass roads, color-coding and Apartheid Wall are symbols of bankruptcy of thought and spirit, of a colonial occupation that is following the brutal logic of its European predecessors that failed to crush a people’s spirit. When emptiness of thought and brute force becomes the only logic supporting a colonial enterprise then the failure and collapse is a forgone conclusion. While the violence is difficult and exerting a heavy daily tool on people’s lives, nevertheless, Israel has not succeeded in crushing the Palestinian spirit and it will never be able to do so. How to respond and end the ongoing brutalization of the Palestinians should be the only focus of conversations and discussions! Gone are the days of approaching Palestine with a symmetry lens that equates between occupiers and occupied while asserting a call for equality of narrative between the sadistic torturer and its tortured prisoners.
Palestinians are physically occupied but mentally are a free people. What Palestinians ask of the global solidarity movement is to break away from their own psychologically constructed occupations and act to free themselves, so as to end their own government’s complicity that enables funds and protects the Israeli occupation at every turn. Yes, express sympathies and shed tears for Palestine, but more valuable, work to counter the multiple violent Israeli structures that kill and maim Palestinians — and do so, at the local level. Don’t focus on whether this is the 3rd of 14th intifada, rather, the time has come for each and everyone to express in deeds, a commitment for a free Palestine and an end to the siege on Gaza. In this regard, the time is right for a more intense engagement with the boycott, divestment and sanctions, as well as, creating programs and projects that can break the walls of oppression and indifference toward Palestine in every city and alleyway across the world. In every corner of the world, there is a persecuted people waiting to be free and the time is now and the call for all to join this effort to act locally to bring a global change.
Dr. Hatem Bazian is co-editor and founder of the Islamophobia Studies Journal and director of the Islamophobia Research and Documentation Project, and a senior lecturer in the Departments of Near Eastern and Ethnic Studies at the University of California, Berkeley. The text is reproduced here with his permission (originally published on: Medium, The Palestine Project, October 18, 2015: click here).
Voor het archief klik hier!
- *Amira HASS: "On the Margins of the Murder”, (Haaretz, Nov 12, 2017): click here!
Mohammed Musa would not have been shot while giving his sister a ride if it weren’t for the soldiers sent to guard an illegal outpost.
- "Israeli forces detain 11 Palestinians, including 4 minors, in overnight raids" (Ma'an, March 29, 2017).
- Amira HASS: "Israeli Settlers Kill a Sheep in Latest Escalation in Jordan Valley, Palestinians Say" (Haaretz, Feb 18, 2017).
- "Israel aims to ‘Judaize’ historical Bethlehem village" (Middle East Monitor, Jan 13, 2017).
- Nasouh NAZZAL: "Israel’s pesticide war on Gazan farmers" (Gulf News Palestine, Dec 26, 2016).
- Emily MULDER: "Israeli guard: 'Go from this land or I will kill you'" (Al Jazeera, Dec 26, 2016).
- "A six-year-old Palestinian girl killed after being run over by Israeli settler" (Middle East Children Alliance, 2016).
- Gideon LEVY & Alex LEVAC: "In Some of the Israeli Army's Raids, Leaving Empty-handed Is Not an Option" (Haaretz, Aug 27, 2016).
- "Israeli settlers attack Palestinian girl in Ramallah, stab and kill her sheep" (Ma'an, Aug 5, 2016).
- "Un enfant palestinien [de 12 ans] tué par des soldats israéliens" (Libération, 19 juillet 2016).
- Kit O'CONNELL: "Israel Cutting Palestinians Off From Their Own Water Supply" (MintPress News, June 30, 2016).
- "Israeli Soldiers Kill A Palestinian Child Near Ramallah" (IMEMC, June 21, 2016).
- Edo KONRAD: "Tel Aviv mayor says the occupation is a cause of Palestinian terror" (+972, June 9, 2016).
- "After being shot three days ago by IOF, Palestinian youth dies from injuries" (Palestinian Information Center, June 6, 2016).
- Palestine PMO: Israel’s destruction of Palestinian water infrastructure is atrocious (Palestine News Network, May 26, 2016).
- Again, settlers burn Palestinian farms in West Bank (Days of Palestine, May 16, 2016).
- Michal ZAK: "Third intifada, terror wave, the 'situation': Just don't mention the 'O' word to Israelis" (Middle East Eye, March 13, 2016).
- Jon QUEALLY: "Brother and Sister, Children Aged 10 and 6, Killed by Israeli Bombing in Gaza" (Common Dreams, March 13, 2016).
- Jonathan COOK: "Aid subversion report makes for shocking reading" (The National, March 7, 2016).
- "Palestijns meisje van 13 geëxecuteerd" (alexandrina.nl, 23 jan, 2016).
- "UN decries Abu Nuwar demolitions, calls for immediate end to planned transfers" (Medical Aid for Palestinians, MAP, Jan 20, 2016).
- Julie PUTSEYS: "Palestijnse empowerment op Israëlische scholen." Geen gelijke kansen zonder evenwaardig onderwijs. Zo denkt de Arabisch-Israëlische professor Dalia Fadila er alleszins over. (MO*, 10 Jan 2016).
- Uri SAVIR: "Why solving Israel-Palestine conflict is still key for regional stability" (Al-Monitor, Jan 3, 2016).
- C.J.WERLEMAN: "The road to hell is paved with 'national security'". Israel is turning the West’s fixation on the Islamic State group into an opportunity to expand its apartheid laws and militarisation of the West Bank (Middle East Eye, Jan 1, 2016).
- Mazal MUALEM: "'Hate wedding' video offers glimpse at Jewish terror" (Al-Monitor, Dec 28, 2015).
- Maureen Clare MURPHY: "Catastrophe for Syrians and Palestinians alike in war-ravaged country" (The Electronic Intifada, Dec 23, 2015).
- Shlomi ELDAR: "Why the US is part of Middle East problem, not the solution". Interview with Ayman Odeh (Al-Monitor, Dec 14, 2015).
- Philip WEISS: "Obama’s ISIS czar says we can’t defeat extremism without resolving Palestinian issue" (Mondoweiss, Dec 14, 2015).
- Uri SAVIR: "How the Islamic State hurts Palestinian cause" (Al-Monitor, Dec 6, 2015).
- Al Jazeera: "Gaza's crumbling healthcare system" (Yahoo.com, Dec 8, 2015).
- Nurit CANETTI: "The radicalization of Israel" (Al-Monitor, Dec 2, 2015).
- Kate: "Prominent Israeli settler runs over 16-year-old girl, then shoots her dead" (Mondoweiss, Nov 23, 2015).
- Gideon LEVY: "So These Are Israel's New Heroes?" Israel's recent military operations in Palestinian hospitals are a blatant violation of the Geneva Convention, and make you wonder how low the country can sink (Haaretz, Nov 21, 2015).
- Philip WEISS: "The best way for Americans to defeat the Islamic state is to end support for Jewish nationalism" (Mondoweiss, Nov 15, 2015).
- Ahmed MOOR: "The Problem of Palestine is Zionism" (Fair Observer, Nov 11, 2015).
- Miko PELED: "Zionism is racism: Notes from Tel-Rumeida, Hebron, El-Khalil" (American Herald Tribune, Nov 13, 2015).
- Megan HANNA: "‘It Has Become A Prison’: The ghettoization of Hebron" (Mondoweiss, Nov 11, 2015).
- Avigail ABARBANEL: "Netanyahu’s craziness is calculated, to drive out Palestinians" (Mondoweiss, Nov 5, 2015).
- Michel WARSCHAWSKI: "La jeunesse palestinienne à couteaux tirés avec Israël" (Orient XXI, 15 Oct 2015).
- Kamel HAWWASH: "Palestinians have a problem with occupiers not (with) Jews" (MEMO, Oct 30, 2015).
- "Palestijnse baby vermoord met traangas" (Alexandrina, Oct 31, 2015).
- Ali ABUNIMAH: "Israel’s executions of Palestinian teens must end, Amnesty says" (The Electronic Intifada, Oct 28, 2015).
- Killian REDDEN: "Hebron at eye of the storm as death toll rises" (Ma'an News Agency, Oct 26, 2015).
- "Netanyahu Shamelessly Exploits the Shoah to Stoke Fear of Palestinians" (Jewish Voice for Peace, Oct 21, 2015).
- Amos GVIRTZ: "From Unilateral- to Bilateral War - or: How the Palestinians Fight to Prevent Being Expelled From the Country" (Occupation Magazine, Oct 20, 2015).
- Noam SHEIZAF: "Jerusalem, in context" (+972, October 19, 2015). "The current events in Jerusalem have a political history and context. Attempts to attribute the violence to some kind of Palestinian pathology while ignoring other factors is a recipe for making things worse."
- Meron RAPOPORT: "The paradox of Jerusalem" (Middle East Eye, October 17, 2015).